Discover The Amazing Persuasion Secrets That The Authorities Want Banned!

Showing posts with label anchor manipulation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label anchor manipulation. Show all posts

Friday, August 29, 2008

Protect yourself against the power of persuasion

How to we defend against persuasion tactics? Firstly we must identify and understand what type of persuasion strategies these people are using; and we must also not deny the fact that we are vulnerable to influences. I know, it is easier said than done... true. Let's go through some ways to build up our defenses against attacks by deceitful manipulators.

Dr Levine has identified some specific techniques on how to combat manipulation:

Stinging
; as in the kind of feeling you would get after being stunk by a bee. Yes - pain, but not physical pain. Levine describes this technique as 'rubbing it in their faces' after they have been exploited by manipulation. Those manipulated are, in Levine's words, 'forced to acknowledge their own personal susceptibility'. Tests have shown that after being told they were duped, subjects became more aware, and are able to recognize manipulativeness in the experimental advertisements shown to them.

The Stinging technique has 2 advantages:

  1. It motivates us to take preventive measures after being forced to see our illusion of vulnerability
  2. Stinging creates an inoculation effect in us

The Inoculation Method. The Inoculation technique states that if we expose people to weak versions of a persuasive message, they will be less vulnerable, and more resistant to stronger persuasive messages later.

Levine mentioned that people from the West, like the United States, and Europe are less susceptible to persuasive messages because of their innate tendency and ability to be critical to persuasion techniques. A reason for this is in the West, people are more individualistic than their Eastern counterparts.

Whereas in the East like those from Japan and China, people tend to scrutinize less and are more open to collaboration, even if they are confronted by an opposing sales message. Because of this characteristics, those from the East are more likely to be influenced by persuasive messages. Levine mentioned, for this reason they (those from the East) 'have little opportunity to build up their antibodies for persuasive messages'. Levine further quoted, 'without a history of inoculation, they're susceptible to even small doses'.


Scripts
. Scripts, as it's name implies, is the usage of rehearse scripts to avoid falling into the persuasion trap. This technique is simple to adopt if you train your subconscious to respond a certain way. For example, the practice of saying 'No' whenever you are approached by a salesman to buy something. Or giving an excuse to leave in the middle of a sales pitch. It can be done using third party as well, such as 'my wife will not approve', or 'my wife will beat the s*#t out of me if she finds out' in order to break out of the influencing process and escape with all your money in your pockets intact.


Practice Critical Thinking. Basically, think with your head and not with your heart or emotions. Too get out of that sales message trance you just have to think logically. Just like a physicist who collects data, processes them and creates a hypothesis. Here's an easy way remember how to perform this technique. Known as the PROACT method, created by J. Hammond, R. Keeney, and H. Raiffa. PROACT is the acronym for: Problem, Objectives, Alternatives, Consequences, and Trade-offs.

Basically what you need to do is:
  • Define the exact problem
  • Think through where you are going with this decision
  • Think of alternate course of actions you can take, and also whether you would have made the decision you made without having choices
  • Evaluate the consequences of the decision who'd make
  • What are the trade-offs of your actions?
2 additional steps is to:

  • Ask, how will your decision effect you in the future, and
  • to think of future consequences after you've made the decision

Take yourself out of the context - Reframe your problems

Look at the situation in a third party perspective. Look at yourself. Levine mentions that those who are vulnerable to manipulations are those in unfamiliar situations, and/or have no clear measure of value.

As humans we tend to justify uncertainty. When we are uncertain, we are more vulnerable and prone to manipulative suggestions. Levine further advices in his book, The Power of Persuasion: How We're Bought and Sold, 'learn to recognize when people try to trap you with faulty comparisons'.

How do you do this?

Anwswer: look at the situation in different perspective, and see how different perspective effects your decision


Ask yourself discomforting questions

Do not easily react to answer a question quickly, take the time to be a contrarian or a skeptic to analyze the flip side.

Levine tells us to postpone the situation when making important decisions, and

  • Search for conflicting information. Be open minded and tackle the situation in all directions
  • Find a person to play devil's advocate. Ask someone to tell you why you shouldn't make that decision
  • When seeking advice from others, be careful not to lead them on. Seek advice from honest and neutral opinionated people. Not from those who will agree to everything you say

Problems with following the majority

A common notion is to agree with the majority's decision. Too often we fall prey to this type of peer pressure, or conformity pressures described as 'Groupthink' by psychologist, Irving Janis.
Janis, mentions that we go through a state of self-censorship where we are hesitant to challenge the majority because of the fear of being ridicule or to waste the group's time.

Groupthink often leads people to follow the decisions of the group leader, and if the leader's opinions are deceitful, or deceptive, those in the group are likely to fall prey to such manipulations because of their heighten illusion of vulnerability.

Therefore, Levine advices to:
  1. Speak your mind in such situations
  2. Choose a leader who accepts different opinions and is open to criticism
  3. Appoint someone as the role of devil's advocate
  4. Have a cooling off period after a decision has been reached and discuss the decision made at another time

Friday, August 8, 2008

Anchor point and anchor trap

Anchor manipulation is one of my favorite topics under the Contrast Principle to discuss. We shall see how easily it is to manipulation someone based on their anchor points.

In The Power of Persuasion: How We're Bought and Sold, Dr. Levine explains the different ways we are manipulated; they are:

The base rate fallacy. The base rate fallacy suggest that sometimes we use the wrong anchor point, or base rate. We may for example base our decisions on stereo type believes, or past conditioned influences and habits. And even due to plain ignorance and laziness to understand a product better than to just accept marketing messages and sales pitches as facts.

An example put forth by Levine is Bayer, the aspirin maker. Bayer's advertisement boast on how their product contain '100% pure aspirin'. The average consumer may be attracted to this point and feel that Bayer aspirin is superior than other brands. Little known to aspirin consumers is that ALL aspirin contains 100% of the drug.

Another example quoted by Levine is Anacin. Anacin added caffeine to their aspirin, and instead of promoting their brand of aspirin they made a statement that 'Anacin contains the pain reliever doctors recommend most'.

With a little clever twisting of words your contrast may have just gotten more intricate.


The decoy. The decoy ploy is initiated by showing customers a variety of optional similar products in the product range that he/she will not buy for a number of reasons like high price or an unattractive feature. As a result another product that the marketer ultimately intents to sell will look more attractive to the customer.

Another explanation will be:

The decoy item is placed together with other items. And by down selling that item (usually a higher price item), it makes the other item seem more value for your dough and reduces buyer's dissonance.

An interesting experiment done by Itamar Simonson and Amos Tversky illustrates an example with an oven:

One set of customers were given a choice between a $179 Panasonic oven, or a $109 Emerson oven; both with a 35% discount offer. Another set of customers were given a third choice of a $199 Panasonic oven with only a 10% discount.

The results of the experiment showed that when the second Panasonic oven was not offered, 57% of the customers chose the cheaper Emerson model, and 47% bought the Panasonic. But when the $199 Panasonic oven was 1 of the 3 options given, 60% of the customers chose to buy the cheaper $179 Panasonic oven, and only 27% bought the Emerson model. 13% of the of customers bought the more expensive Panasonic oven.

What this experiment reveal is that when a more expensive version of the same brand is offered, the cheaper model of that brand is likely to be more attractive and sold.

Another great example is masking a decoy with a decoy, described by Levine is that of a sweater store:

Customers lured by a sales promotion comes into the store and sees a messy table (on the right-hand side of course) with leftover cashmere sweaters at 40% off (this is the decoy of the decoy). Then walking further down in the same direction the customer sees another similar table selling cotton sweaters that were priced 20% to 30% higher than the cashmere the customer saw earlier (this is the decoy). Now further down the customer sees a neatly arranged colorful table with similar cashmere sweaters at prices lower than the 40% off cashmere and much lower than the decoy sweaters.

So you can guess what the result was - yes, customers rushed to grab what was laid out on the last table.


Anchor Trap

I would like to end this section by warning you of the anchor trap. An anchor trap is usually used to make a high priced appear lower. I will leave you with the following example by Dr. Robert Levine of a cable provider in Kentucky:

Storer Cable Communications wanted to raise subscriber rates, mailed out a notice saying:

"It's not often you get good news instead of a bill, but we've got some for you. If you've heard all those rumors about your basic cable rate going up $10 or more a month, you can relax: it's not going to happen! The great news is... the rate for basic cable is increasing only $2 a month."


What happened? Storer managed to secure an extra $2 per month from their customer's monthly cable bill by letting the customer think that they were saving on $8 per month. How? Because rates were expected to go up by $10 (or more) a month.